Education Inequality in Pakistan: Why the State Must Do More Than Cut Fees
Education inequality in Pakistan is widening because state policy has not leveled the field between rich and poor children. Economist Faisal Bari argues that fee cuts and a few scholarships are not enough, and that equal opportunities in education need health support, mentoring, counselling and job transition programmes.
Background: Two Children, Two Very Different Futures
Picture two girls born in the same country. One grows up in a wealthy home, attends an expensive private school and receives constant academic support from her parents. She sits international examinations, enters a top university and graduates with a strong network behind her.
The other girl belongs to a family that struggles to keep her in a public or low fee private school. She probably drops out long before college. If she does reach university, she faces a weak job market with little confidence, little guidance and no family contacts to open doors. Millions of Pakistani children live this second story, and it explains why education inequality in Pakistan has become a national concern.
In theory, the state exists to narrow this gap. Education is one of the strongest tools for creating a level playing field, because a child’s talent can matter more than her family’s income. Article 25A of the Constitution makes free and compulsory education a legal right, and Pakistan has made international commitments on the same promise.
Details: Where the System Is Failing
The numbers show how far the promise has slipped. Around 26 million children are out of school, and the problem of out of school children in Pakistan touches every province. Many who do enrol attend schools where learning quality is poor. Dropout rates are high, and only about 10 per cent of enrolled children reach university.
Even graduates face a difficult road. The quality of teaching in many public and private universities is weak, and decent jobs are scarce. A degree no longer guarantees a livelihood, which makes the whole climb feel uncertain for poor families.
How State Policy Deepened the Gap
Faisal Bari, a senior research fellow at the Institute of Development and Economic Alternatives and an associate professor of economics at LUMS, writes that policy has often made things worse. In his Dawn column published on November 20, he points to funding cuts and restrictions on public schools and universities. He also notes that the state has not regulated private, for profit education providers.
Scholarships exist, and some reward students who perform well in public examinations. Compared with the scale of poverty and the rising cost of education, however, he describes them as a few drops in the ocean. Education inequality in Pakistan therefore continues, even where the state has tried to help.
The Limits of Nonprofit Efforts
Nonprofit organisations have stepped in, and their work matters. The Citizens Foundation, probably the largest nonprofit schooling provider in the country, has operated for more than three decades. It has served hundreds of thousands of students and employed thousands of teachers.
Yet it runs fewer than 3,000 schools and school units, while Pakistan has roughly 200,000 schools. The gap between what nonprofits can reach and what the country needs is enormous. Bari asks a simple question: how many such organisations would we need? His answer is that it cannot be done without the state.
Quotes and Expert View: Access Alone Is Not Enough
Bari’s central argument is that the state role in education cannot stop at fees and subsidies. Public schools are already free and public universities are still subsidised, yet poor students keep falling behind. Reducing tuition solves an access problem, but it does not solve the deeper problem of unequal preparation.
He explains that young people from disadvantaged homes need a wider package of support. This includes health and nutrition, academic help where homes cannot provide it, career counselling, mentoring, and training in communication and self presentation. Confidence building and help with the move into the workplace complete the list. In his words, “It cannot be done without the state.”
Such programmes are almost entirely missing in Pakistan. Even technical and vocational training centres tend to focus on narrow skills rather than on confidence and interpersonal ability. A graduate may know a trade and still struggle in an interview because nobody ever taught her how to present herself.
Local Models Worth Studying
Bari highlights two small local initiatives. Amal Academy runs fellowships with university students over a few months. Its structured and interactive mentorship programmes for students focus on self presentation, confidence and better self management.
The Institute of Lifelong Learning and Development is a newer effort with a three part strategy. It offers scholarships to ease access, development and mentorship programmes to build skills and confidence, and a service culture from day one. Beneficiaries are encouraged to pay it forward as soon as they begin.
Impact: What This Means for Pakistan’s Future
The effects of unequal opportunity reach well beyond the classroom. When talented children from poor families cannot progress, the economy loses skills it badly needs. A merit based society draws on the best talent available, and that talent drives growth, social well being and harmony.
Weak education outcomes also hold back human development. Employers struggle to find work ready graduates, while young people lose faith that effort leads to reward. Over time, this can deepen social divisions and widen the gap between privileged and ordinary households. Readers following our wider coverage of the education sector in Pakistan will recognise how closely these issues connect.
Policy bodies can act on the lessons from local programmes. Bari suggests that institutions such as TEVTA and PSDF could scale up the best of these models. Expanding them through public systems would reach far more students than small initiatives can manage alone.
Conclusion: A Case for Real Paths
The message of the column is clear. Pakistan cannot move toward better human development and lasting economic growth while millions of children face unequal opportunity sets. Tackling education inequality in Pakistan requires the state to do more than lower costs.
A real level playing field needs mentoring, guidance, skills training and support through the transition to work, alongside access to schools. If policymakers learn from successful local models and fund them at scale, equal opportunities in education could become a reality rather than a slogan. For more analysis on these themes, follow our Pakistan news and analysis and explore our opinion and explainer coverage.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is education inequality in Pakistan?
Education inequality in Pakistan describes the large gap between the schooling that rich and poor children receive. Wealthy children attend high fee schools, get strong support at home and enjoy useful networks. Poor children often attend weak schools, drop out early and face few job prospects, even when they are equally talented.
How many children are out of school in Pakistan?
Around 26 million children are currently out of school, according to the figures cited in the Dawn column. This is one of the largest out of school populations in the world. Many other children are enrolled but receive poor quality education, so the real learning gap is wider than enrolment numbers suggest.
What does Article 25A of the Constitution say?
Article 25A makes free and compulsory education a legal right for children in Pakistan, within the age range set by law. It places a duty on the state to provide basic schooling. Critics argue that implementation has fallen far short, which is why so many children remain outside classrooms.
Why are scholarships not enough to solve the problem?
Scholarships help individual students, but their scale is tiny compared with the number of children living in poverty. They also address only the cost of study. Many students need academic support, counselling, mentoring and confidence building, which scholarships alone do not provide, so the wider gap stays open.
What can the state do to create equal opportunities in education?
The state can restore and increase funding for public schools and universities, and regulate private for profit providers. It can also build programmes for health, nutrition, mentoring and career counselling. Scaling successful local models through bodies such as TEVTA and PSDF would help students move from education into real jobs.